Survey of NF1 inactivation by surrogate immunohistochemistry in ovarian carcinomas.

OBJECTIVE: Inhibition of the MAPK pathway by MEK inhibitors (MEKi) is currently a therapeutic standard in several cancer types, including ovarian low-grade serous carcinoma (LGSC). A common MAPK pathway alteration in tubo-ovarian high-grade serous carcinoma (HGSC) is the genomic inactivation of neurofibromin 1 (NF1). The primary objectives of our study were to survey the prevalence of NF1 inactivation in the principal ovarian carcinoma histotype as well as to evaluate its associations with clinico-pathological parameters and key biomarkers including BRCA1/2 status in HGSC. METHODS: A recently commercialized NF1 antibody (clone NFC) was orthogonally validated on an automated immunohistochemistry (IHC) platform and IHC was performed on tissue microarrays containing 2140 ovarian carcinoma cases. Expression was interpreted as loss/inactivated (complete or subclonal) versus normal/retained. RESULTS: Loss of NF1 expression was detected in 250/1429 (17.4%) HGSC including 11% with subclonal loss. Survival of NF1-inactivated HGSC patients was intermediate between favorable BRCA1/2 mutated HGSC and unfavorable CCNE1 high-level amplified HGSC. NF1 inactivation was mutually exclusive with CCNE1 high-level amplifications, co-occurred with RB1 loss and occurred at similar frequencies in BRCA1/2 mutated versus wild-type HGSC. NF1 loss was found in 21/286 (7.3%) endometrioid carcinomas with a favorable prognostic association (p = 0.048), and in 4/64 (5.9%) LGSC, mutually exclusive with other driver events. CONCLUSIONS: NF1 inactivation occurs in a significant subset of BRCA1/2 wild-type HGSC and a subset of LGSC. While the functional effects of NF1 inactivation need to be further characterized, this signifies a potential therapeutic opportunity to explore targeting NF1 inactivation in these tumors.

Molecular subtype stratified outcomes according to adjuvant therapy in endometrial cancer.

OBJECTIVES: Recent data support the predictive implications of molecular subtype assignment in endometrial cancer (EC). Our objective was to retrospectively assess clinical outcomes according to adjuvant treatment received within EC molecular subtypes. METHODS: Clinical outcomes (disease-specific and progression-free survival DSS/PFS) of EC patients from a single institution and population-based cohorts that had undergone molecular classification were assessed with respect to adjuvant therapy received and 2016 ESMO risk group. RESULTS: 2472 ECs were assessed; 184 (7.4%) POLEmut, 638 (25.8%) MMRd, 1223 (49.5%) NSMP and 427 (17.3%) p53abn. N = 774 (34.6%) of the cohort were ESMO 2016 high risk and 109 (4.8%) were advanced or metastatic. In patients with MMRd EC, assessed across and within stage, there was no observed benefit in DSS or PFS with the addition of chemotherapy +/- radiation compared to radiation alone in ESMO high risk (p = 0.694) or ESMO high, advanced, metastatic risk groups combined (p = 0.852). In patients with p53abn EC, adjuvant chemotherapy given with radiation was associated with significantly longer DSS compared to radiation alone in ESMO high risk (p = 0.007) and ESMO high, advanced and metastatic risk groups combined (p = 0.015), even when restricted to stage I disease (p < 0.001) and when compared in serous vs. non-serous histotypes (p = 0.009). CONCLUSIONS: Adjuvant chemotherapy is associated with more favorable outcomes for patients with p53abn EC, including stage I disease and non-serous histotypes, but does not appear to add benefit within MMRd ECs for any stage of disease, consistent with PORTEC-3 molecular subanalysis. Prospective trials, assessing treatment efficacy within molecular subtype are needed, however these 'real-world' data should be considered when discussing adjuvant treatment with patients.

Grade and Estrogen Receptor Expression Identify a Subset of No Specific Molecular Profile Endometrial Carcinomas at a Very Low Risk of Disease-Specific Death.

Endometrial carcinoma (EC) can be divided into 4 prognostic molecular subtypes, and no specific molecular profile (NSMP) type is the most commonly occurring type (∼50%). Although described as having an intermediate to favorable prognosis, this subtype encompasses pathologically and molecularly diverse tumors. We aimed to identify factors associated with outcomes within the NSMP ECs that might be used to stratify prognosis and direct treatment. Clinicopathologic, immunohistochemical, and genetic features of a large series of NSMP EC were used to identify parameters that could identify the subset associated with a very favorable outcome (disease-specific death rate <5% at 5 years, termed low-risk NSMP). A total of 1110 NSMP ECs were profiled. In a univariate analysis, stage, grade, lymphovascular invasion, estrogen receptor (ER) and progesterone receptor (PR) expression, L1CAM overexpression, and mutations in PIK3CA were associated with disease-specific survival. Two critical features, grade and ER expression, identified a low-risk NSMP subset (grade 1-2, ER-positive [>1%], 84% of cases), which showed a 5-year disease-specific death rate of 1.6% across all stages and 1.4% within stage I. The remaining cases (high-risk NSMPs, grade 3, and/or ER-negative status) were responsible for most of the disease-specific deaths (disease-specific death rate at 5 years, 22.9%; hazard ratio compared with that of low-risk NSMPs: 16.3; 95% CI, 8.4-31.7). Within NSMP EC, the low-risk and high-risk categories were of prognostic significance independent of the stage on a multivariate analysis. Low-grade and ER-positive NSMP ECs are a homogeneous low-risk group associated with an exceptionally favorable prognosis in which de-escalation and/or endocrine therapy strategies can be applied. Grade 3 and/or ER-negative status identifies a high-risk NSMP subset, including rare high-grade histotypes (eg, clear cell, dedifferentiated, and mesonephric-like), responsible for most NSMP-related deaths. Subclassification of NSMPs allows for the category of low-risk EC molecular subtypes to be dramatically expanded because it now includes both POLEmut and the much more common low-risk NSMP EC.

Variability in endometrial carcinoma pathology practice: opportunities for improvement with molecular classification.

We assessed the landscape of diagnostic pathology practice and how molecular classification could potentially impact management of patients with endometrial cancer by collecting patient samples, clinicopathologic data, and patient outcomes from EC patients diagnosed in 2016 at 10 Canadian tertiary cancer centers and 19 community hospitals. ProMisE molecular subtype (POLEmut, MMRd, p53abn, No Specific Molecular Profile (NSMP)) was assigned retrospectively. 1357 patients were fully evaluable including 85 POLEmut (6.3%), 380 MMRd (28.0%), 643 NSMP (47.4%), and 249 p53abn ECs (18.3%). Immunohistochemistry (IHC) for MMR proteins was undertaken at the time of primary diagnosis in 2016 in only 42% of the cohort (570/1357; range 3.5-95.4%/center). p53 IHC had only been performed in 21.1% of the cohort (286/1357; range 10.1-41.9%/center). Thus, based on the retrospective molecular subtype assignment, 54.7% (208/380) of MMRd EC had not been tested with MMR IHC (or MSI) and 48.2% (120/249) of p53abn ECs were not tested with p53 IHC in 2016. Molecular subtype diversity within histotypes was profound; most serous carcinomas were p53abn (91.4%), but only 129/249 (51.8%) p53abn EC were serous. Low-grade (Gr1-2) endometrioid carcinomas were mostly NSMP (589/954, 61.7%) but included all molecular subtypes, including p53abn (19/954, 2.0%). Molecular subtype was significantly associated with clinical outcomes (p < 0.001) even in patients with stage I disease (OS p = 0.006, DSS p < 0.001, PFS p < 0.001). Assessment of national pathologic practice in 2016 shows highly variable use of MMR and p53 IHC and demonstrates significant opportunities to improve and standardize biomarker reporting. Inconsistent, non-reflexive IHC resulted in missed opportunities for Hereditary Cancer Program referral and Lynch Syndrome diagnosis, and missed potential therapeutic implications (e.g., chemotherapy in p53abn EC, immune blockade for MMRd EC). Routine integration of molecular subtyping into practice can improve the consistency of EC pathology assessment and classification.

Variation in practice in endometrial cancer and potential for improved care and equity through molecular classification.

OBJECTIVES: We measured the variation in practice across all aspects of endometrial cancer (EC) management and assessed the potential impact of implementation of molecular classification. METHODS: Centers from across Canada provided representative tumor samples and clinical data, including preoperative workup, operative management, hereditary cancer program (HCP) referrals, adjuvant therapy, surveillance and outcomes, for all EC patients diagnosed in 2016. Tumors were classified into the four ProMisE molecular subtypes. RESULTS: A total of 1336 fully evaluable EC patients were identified from 10 tertiary cancer centers (TC; n = 1022) and 19 community centers (CC; n = 314). Variation of surgical practice across TCs was profound (14-100%) for lymphadenectomy (LND) (mean 57% Gr1/2, 82% Gr3) and omental sampling (20% Gr1/2, 79% Gr3). Preoperative CT scans were inconsistently obtained (mean 32% Gr1/2, 51% Gr3) and use of adjuvant chemo or chemoRT in high risk EC ranged from 0-55% and 64-100%, respectively. Molecular subtyping was performed retrospectively and identified 6% POLEmut, 28% MMRd, 48% NSMP and 18% p53abn ECs, and was significantly associated with survival. Within patients retrospectively diagnosed with MMRd EC only 22% had been referred to HCP. Of patients with p53abn EC, LND and omental sampling was not performed in 21% and 23% respectively, and 41% received no chemotherapy. Comparison of management in 2016 with current 2020 ESGO/ESTRO/ESP guidelines identified at least 26 and 95 patients that would have been directed to less or more adjuvant therapy, respectively (10% of cohort). CONCLUSION: Molecular classification has the potential to mitigate the profound variation in practice demonstrated in current EC care, enabling reproducible risk assessment, guiding treatment and reducing health care disparities.

Comparison of p53 immunohistochemical staining in differentiated vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia (dVIN) with that in inflammatory dermatoses and benign squamous lesions in the vulva.

AIMS: Differentiated vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia (dVIN), the precursor lesion to human papillomavirus-independent vulvar squamous cell carcinoma (VSCC), can be difficult to distinguish from vulvar inflammatory dermatoses. Our goal was to determine if p53 could be a useful biomarker for dVIN, by characterizing p53 percentage, intensity and patterns of staining in dVIN and its histological mimics. METHODS AND RESULTS: We studied p53 immunohistochemical staining patterns in 16 dVIN cases and 46 vulvar non-neoplastic squamous lesions [12 lichen sclerosus (LS); seven lichen simplex chronicus; three lichen planus (LP); six psoriasis; 13 spongiotic dermatitis (SPO); and five candidiasis]. dVIN cases were adjacent to a p16-negative invasive VSCC in resection specimens. All dVIN cases showed null-type or moderate to strong uniform p53 staining in >70% of basal cells, with moderate to strong continuous parabasal staining extending to two-thirds of the epidermis. This was in contrast to weak or weak to moderate patchy p53 staining in the majority of other lesions. Moderate to strong and increased basal p53 staining (≥70%) was also observed in a subset of LS cases (5/12, 42%), LP cases (1/3, 33%), and SPO cases (36%, 4/11); however, in all categories, this was limited to the basal layer, and any staining in the parabasal layers was patchy. CONCLUSION: Strong and uniform p53 staining of basal cells, extending into the parabasal layers, and a complete absence of staining (null type) is useful in distinguishing dVIN from other mimics in the vulva. p53 staining of lesser intensity or quantity, particularly basal overexpression only, overlaps with that in vulvar inflammatory lesions.

Diagnostic Variation in p53 Usage for Endometrial Carcinoma Diagnosis: Implications for Molecular Subtyping.

Immunostaining for p53 is widely but variably used when diagnosing endometrial carcinoma (EC). Mutant-pattern p53 staining can support a diagnosis of serous carcinoma, and also serve as a surrogate test for identifying the "serous-like" subset of aggressive EC identified by The Cancer Genome Atlas characterized by high numbers of somatic copy number abnormalities. We, retrospectively, assessed WHO histotype, usage of p53 immunostaining, and p53 status in a consecutive series of biopsies showing EC from a single hospital. Of 79 ECs, 59 (75%) were low-grade EC (LGEC), 13 (16%) high-grade EC (HGEC), and 7 (9%) were serous. p53 immunostaining was performed at the time of diagnosis in 27/79 (34%) biopsies; 6/7 of serous histotype, 11/13 HGEC, and 10/59 LGEC. Mutant-pattern p53 staining was present in 6/6 serous, 2/11 HGEC, and 2/10 LGEC. The remaining 53 tumors subsequently had p53 immunostaining done; all 49 LGEC showed wild-type staining and the serous carcinoma and 1/2 HGEC showed mutant pattern staining. While there are no guidelines on using p53 in endometrial biopsies, this study shows consistent usage in high-grade histotypes and variable usage in LGEC. As 100% (7/7) of serous EC and 3% (2/59) of the LGECs showed mutant-pattern p53 staining, histotype may serve as a surrogate for p53 assessment, such that only HGEC or ambiguous carcinomas should be routinely subjected to p53 immunostaining.

Targeted Molecular and Immunohistochemical Analyses of Endometrial Clear Cell Carcinoma Show that POLE Mutations and DNA Mismatch Repair Protein Deficiencies Are Uncommon.

Endometrial clear cell carcinoma (ECCC) is an uncommon histotype without unique identified molecular alterations. Recently, The Cancer Genome Atlas molecular subtypes have been reported in ECCC. ECCC cases were collected from 11 institutions with diagnoses confirmed by morphologic review and immunohistochemistry. DNA mismatch repair (MMR) proteins, p53 expression, and ARID1A expression was assessed by immunohistochemistry on tissue microarrays. Targeted next-generation sequencing was completed for POLE, TP53, KRAS, and PIK3CA. Pathogenicity of mutations was determined using MutationTaster and PolyPhen databases. For p53, immunohistochemistry and sequencing were complimentarily used to assess the p53 status. Of 57 cases, 46 were considered prototypical ECCC by morphology and immunohistochemical profile (Napsin A-positive and ER-negative). Three cases were excluded because of insufficient sample for complete immunohistochemical analysis, and 6 had failed sequencing, resulting in 37 cases. Of the 37 remaining cases, 6/37 (16%) had predicted pathogenic mutations in the exonuclease domain of POLE with an allelic frequency >10%; however, no hot-spot mutations were identified. No cases were MMR-deficient. The gene most commonly affected was TP53 (59%, 22/37), followed by KRAS (13%, 2/15) and PIK3CA (13%, 2/15). The current study is the largest molecular analysis of pure ECCC reported to date. When strict classification criteria are applied, MMR-deficient and POLE mutated subtypes are not represented. Further consensus on what represents a deleterious POLE mutations is needed. The findings support separately studying histologically/immunohistochemically defined ECCC to identify characteristic molecular alterations in future studies.

Canadian Consensus-based and Evidence-based Guidelines for Benign Endometrial Pathology Reporting in Biopsy Material.

Standardized terminology has proven benefits in cancer reporting; in contrast, reporting of benign diagnoses in endometrial biopsy currently lacks such standardization. Unification and update on the lexicon can provide the structure and consistency needed for optimal patient care and quality assurance purposes. The Special Interest Group in Gynecologic Pathology of the Canadian Association of Pathologists-Association Canadienne des Pathologistes (CAP-ACP) embarked in an initiative to address the current need for consensus terminology in benign endometrial biopsy pathology reporting. Nine members of the Special Interest Group developed a guideline for structured diagnosis of benign endometrial pathology through critical appraisal of the available peer-reviewed literature and joint discussions. The first version of the document was circulated for feedback to a group of professionals in akin fields, the CAP-ACP Executive Committee and the CAP-ACP general membership. The final 1-page document included 17 diagnostic terms comprising the most common benign endometrial entities, as well as explanatory notes for pathologists. The proposed terminology was implemented in the practice of 5 pathologists from the group, who applied the guideline to all benign endometrial biopsies over a 2-wk period. A total of 212 benign endometrial biopsies were evaluated in this implementation step; the recommended terminology adequately covered the diagnosis in 203 cases (95.8%). A list of terminology for benign endometrial biopsy reporting, based on expert consensus and critical appraisal of the available literature, is presented. On the basis of our results of implementation at multiple centers, the proposed guideline can successfully cover the large majority of diagnostic scenarios. The document has the potential to positively impact patient care, promote quality assurance, and facilitate research initiatives aimed at improving histopathologic assessment of benign endometrium.

A Comparison of GATA3, TTF1, CD10, and Calretinin in Identifying Mesonephric and Mesonephric-like Carcinomas of the Gynecologic Tract.

Mesonephric carcinomas of the gynecologic tract are neoplasms that are often under-recognized due to their varied morphologic appearances. Recently, GATA3 and TTF1 have been reported to be useful immunohistochemical markers for distinguishing mesonephric carcinomas from its morphologic mimics. Herein, we compared the performance of GATA3 and TTF1 to the traditional markers used for mesonephric carcinomas, CD10 and calretinin. We studied 694 cases: 8 mesonephric carcinomas (7 cervical [includes 3 mesonephric carcinosarcomas], 1 vaginal), 5 mesonephric-like carcinomas (4 uterine corpus, 1 ovarian), 585 endometrial adenocarcinomas, and 96 cervical adenocarcinomas. Mesonephric-like carcinomas were defined as tumors exhibiting the classic morphologic features of mesonephric carcinoma, but occurring outside of the cervix and without convincing mesonephric remnants. GATA3 had the highest sensitivity and specificity (91% and 94%) compared with TTF1 (45% and 99%), CD10 (73% and 83%), and calretinin (36% and 89%). GATA3, however, also stained a substantial number of uterine carcinosarcomas (23/113, 20%). TTF1 was positive in 5/5 (100%) mesonephric-like carcinomas and only 1/8 (13%) mesonephric carcinomas. In 4/6 (67%) TTF1 positive cases, GATA3 exhibited an inverse staining pattern with TTF1. In summary, GATA3 was the best overall marker for mesonephric and mesonephric-like carcinomas, but cannot be used to distinguish mesonephric carcinosarcomas from Müllerian carcinosarcomas. The inverse staining pattern between GATA3 and TTF1, suggests that TTF1 may be useful when GATA3 is negative in small biopsies where mesonephric or mesonephric-like carcinoma is suspected. The greater TTF1 positivity in mesonephric-like carcinomas suggests they may be biologically different from prototypical mesonephric carcinomas.

HOXB4 Immunoreactivity in Endometrial Tissues From Women With or Without Endometriosis.

Endometriosis is a common disease characterized by the presence of ectopic endometrial tissue. Although the pathogenesis of endometriosis remains unclear, several factors have been implicated, including the dysregulation of homeobox ( HOX) genes. Our objective was to investigate the localization and immunoreactivity of HOXB4 in endometrial tissues from women with or without endometriosis. We studied samples of eutopic endometrium (EE), endometriomas (Eoma), superficial endometriosis (SE), and deep infiltrating endometriosis (DIE) from 34 women with endometriosis, as well as eutopic endometrium from 38 women without endometriosis (EC). HOXB4 localization and immunoreactivity was assessed using immunohistochemistry and histoscore analysis. Data were analyzed with and without stratification by menstrual cycle phase. HOXB4 protein was present in the nuclei of endometrial glandular epithelial cells but not in stromal cells. HOXB4 immunoreactivity was reduced in DIE samples compared to all other groups. A smaller reduction in HOXB4 immunoreactivity was observed in SE samples compared to EC samples. HOXB4 immunoreactivity was significantly greater in proliferative compared to secretory phase samples in the EC group but not in EE, Eoma, or DIE groups. Among only proliferative phase samples, HOXB4 immunoreactivity was reduced in EE, Eoma, and DIE groups compared to EC. Based on these data, we suggest that an impaired capacity of eutopic and ectopic endometrial tissue to upregulate levels of HOXB4 during the proliferative phase may play a role in the pathogenesis of endometriosis and that further downregulation of HOXB4 may enhance ectopic implant invasiveness.

Interobserver Agreement in Endometrial Carcinoma Histotype Diagnosis Varies Depending on The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA)-based Molecular Subgroup.

The Cancer Genome Atlas recently identified a genomic-based molecular classification of endometrial carcinomas, with 4 molecular categories: (1) ultramutated (polymerase epsilon [POLE] mutated), (2) hypermutated (microsatellite instability), (3) copy number abnormalities-low, and (4) copy number abnormalities-high. Two studies have since proposed models to classify endometrial carcinomas into 4 molecular subgroups, modeled after The Cancer Genome Atlas, using simplified and more clinically applicable surrogate methodologies. In our study, 151 endometrial carcinomas were molecularly categorized using sequencing for the exonuclease domain mutations (EDM) of POLE, and immunohistochemistry for p53 and mismatch repair (MMR) proteins. This separated cases into 1 of 4 groups: (1) POLE EDM, (2) MMR-D, (3) p53 wildtype (p53 wt), or (4) p53 abnormal (p53 abn). Seven gynecologic pathologists were asked to assign each case to one of the following categories: grade 1 to 2 endometrioid carcinoma (EC), grade 3 EC, mucinous, serous carcinoma (SC), clear cell, dedifferentiated, carcinosarcoma, mixed, and other. Consensus diagnosis among all 7 pathologists was highest in the p53 wt group (37/41, 90%), lowest in the p53 abn group (14/36, 39%), and intermediate in the POLE EDM (22/34, 65%) and MMR-D groups (23/40, 58%). Although the majority of p53 wt endometrial carcinomas are grade 1 to 2 EC (sensitivity: 90%), fewer than half of grade 1 to 2 EC fell into the p53 wt category (positive predictive value: 42%). Pure SC almost always resided in the p53 abn group (positive predictive value: 96%), but it was insensitive as a marker of p53 abn (sensitivity 64%) and the reproducibility of diagnosing SC was suboptimal. The limitations in the precise histologic classification of endometrial carcinomas highlights the importance of an ancillary molecular-based classification scheme.

Histopathological features of endometrial carcinomas associated with POLE mutations: implications for decisions about adjuvant therapy.

AIMS: To characterize the histomorphological features of endometrial carcinomas (ECs) harbouring polymerase ε (POLE) mutations. METHODS AND RESULTS: Forty-three ECs with POLE mutations were compared with a cohort of 202 ECs. Most POLE-mutated ECs were endometrioid [34/43 (79%)]; the remaining tumours were mixed [6/43 (14%)], serous [2/43 (5%)], and clear cell [1/43 (2%)]. The endometrioid carcinomas were predominantly International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics grade 3 (27/43, 63%). The histotype distribution did not differ from that of control ECs (P = 0.69), but the grade of the EC was higher (P < 0.0005). Both nuclear grade and mitotic index were significantly higher in POLE-mutated ECs than in the comparison cohort. POLE-mutated ECs were associated with peritumoral lymphocytes and numerous tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes. Lymphovascular invasion was present in 20 of 43 tumours. Adjuvant radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy would be offered in up to 80% and 40% of patients, respectively, on the basis of stage, grade, lymphovascular invasion, and histotype. CONCLUSIONS: POLE-mutated ECs are typically of high grade, with prominent lymphocytic infiltration, but they are not sufficiently distinctive to allow accurate diagnosis based on routine haematoxylin and eosin staining. Even though POLE-mutated tumours are associated with an excellent prognosis, current guidelines for giving adjuvant treatment for EC result in most patients receiving adjuvant therapy.

Predicting local recurrence following breast-conserving therapy for early stage breast cancer: the significance of a narrow (≤ 2 mm) surgical resection margin.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Controversy continues over the extent of surgical resection margin required to minimize the risk of local recurrence (LR) in breast-conserving therapy (BCT) for early stage breast cancer. This study explores whether or not a narrow (≤ 2 mm) but negative resection margin affects LR. METHODS: All patients registered at the Saskatoon Cancer Center between January 1, 1991 and December 31, 2000 with a diagnosis of early stage invasive duct carcinoma treated with BCT were examined. All charts and pathology reports were reviewed with a review of the pathology for all cases where the resection margin was unclear in the original report. Other factors known or thought to effect LR (age, radiation boost, grade, extensive DCIS, ER/PR receptor status) were considered in the statistical analysis. RESULTS: Amongst the 200 narrow margin cases 19 LR were detected (19/201 = 9.5%) while 52 LR were detected in the 491 wide margin cases (52/491 =10.6%). This difference was not statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: A narrow (≤ 2 mm) surgical resection margin does not result in an increase in LR compared to a surgical resection margin 2 mm in BCT for early stage duct carcinoma and does not warrant re-excision.